What is the Best Coconut Butter?
When searching for the best coconut butter, there are certain things to consider such as the cost, whether it contains any artificial ingredients, and what it is made from. Considering all of these factors, we chose Nutiva Organic Coconut Manna as our top pick. Nutiva Organic Coconut Manna is naturally extracted from the meat of coconuts, making it a natural and creamy snack or ingredient.
5 Top Coconut Butter: Our Picks & Recommendation
- Best Overall: Nutiva Organic Coconut Manna
- Best Budget: Kevala Organic Coconut Butter
- Best Gluten-Free: Binnie’s Organic Spread
- Best Sugar-Free: Artisana Organics
- Best Creamy: Coconut Country Living Organic
Coconut butter, coconut oil, and pretty much anything coconut has amazing health and beauty benefits. For instance, they can work wonders on hair and skin.
One of my daughters has the driest hair I have ever seen in my life. After trying multiple products to keep it moisturized, I found a blog about using coconut oil and coconut butter in hair.
Having nothing to lose, we gave it a shot and it turned out to be the best decision. There has never been any man-made product to moisturize her hair like natural coconut products have.
If you walk into the grocery store, you may find yourself confused between coconut oil and coconut butter because they have a similar look and consistency when the coconut butter is cold.
The difference in the products is basically what part of the coconut they are made from. Coconut oil is taken from the coconut meat and is missing much of the fat, fiber and nutrients.
It is made from the coconut’s flesh and made into a paste-like substance, somewhat similar to peanut butter. It tends to retain the fat, fiber and nutrients provided by the coconut.
There are tons of brands to chose from that offer different ingredients and are made in different environments with different types of coconuts.
When it comes down to it, the more natural and organic the coconut butter, the more you will benefit.
5 Best Coconut Butter Reviews:
In order to bring you the best coconut butter options, we assessed reviews and ratings from multiple products.
Though it was a tough job, we were able to decrease our list down to the following five options based on their ingredients, textures, taste, and cost.
What You Will Love: This organic coconut butter is a superfood that is good enough to eat straight from the jar.
Nutiva’s Organic Coconut Manna is nutrient dense as it is taken straight from the meat of coconuts without any harmful or chemical processes. It comes in glass jars with BPA free lids for that extra safety step.
Nutiva’s is described as whole coconut puree and is reported to be great for multiple diets including whole food, paleo, ketogenic, and gluten-free diets.
Buyers love the rich buttery texture that is delicious by itself, as an ingredient in tons of recipes including fudge, or as a coconut spread on their favorite bread item.
It is reasonably priced for the taste and health benefits it delivers. The only downside I could find is that many people have a difficult time stirring it in the jar when they first receive it.
However, if you follow the warming directions, that problem is eradicated.
Made straight from the meat of coconuts, comes in recycled glass jars with BPA free lids, reasonable price, great butter substitute for diets, delicious taste.
Need to warm the coconut butter prior to stirring it.
What You Will Love: This non GMO Project verified gourmet food is available at an amazing price.
Kevala Organic Coconut Butter is more of a coconut cream thanks to its creamy texture that buyers love to spread on toast and use for cake frosting.
It is made from pure whole coconut flesh in a soy free, peanut free, dairy free and gluten free facility, keeping those with allergies safe from accidental contamination.
Kevala is available in 16 oz to 36 oz quantities. The 16 oz quantities are stored in glass jars. However, the other quantities are available in BPA free plastic.
The price for any of the quantities is incredibly reasonable. I did find two complaints that the bottom portion of the coconut butter is too tough to mix up, but those were the only two complaints of that issue that I could locate.
Creamy texture, great price, available in multiple quantities, made in safe facilities, stored in safe containers.
Bottom portion may be too tough to mix.
What You Will Love: Binnie’s Coconut Butter is available in four popular flavors: Dark Chocolate, Simple Cinnamon, Very Vanilla, and Just Coconut.
Binnie’s Coconut Butter goes beyond delicious, plain coconut butter by also offering vanilla, chocolate, and cinnamon versions.
It is made from the following mix of natural and organic ingredients: organic extra virgin coconut oil, organic shredded coconut, organic coconut syrup, and sea salt.
Organic cacao is added in for the chocolate flavor, organic vanilla for the Very Vanilla version, and organic cinnamon for the Simply Cinnamon version. It is non GMO, gluten free, and diet friendly.
Users enjoy spreading it on pancakes, crackers, toast, fruit, cakes, and more. The three pack is a somewhat pricey cost, generally ranging between $40 and $50.
However, you do get three jars with delicious versatile flavors, so the price per jar is actually reasonable.
Non-GMO, gluten free, diet friendly, all natural and organic ingredients, tasty spread for multiple foods and snacks, multiple delicious flavors, price per jar very fair.
Overall cost a little high, some users report that its consistency is a little crumbly.
Best Sugar-Free Coconut Butter
What You Will Love: This coconut butter is made from only one ingredient: 100% organic pure ground coconut flesh.
Artisana Organics coconut butter is peanut free, dairy and gluten free, sugar free, and lacks any added oils, GMOs, salt, and pesticides.
You can feel confident when using Artisana that you are only getting what you expect. The company also purchases its produce from organic, family farms so the coconut butter is natural from the beginning to the end.
Buyers love the natural, somewhat intense, flavor, and use the smooth texture on crackers, to make homemade energy bars and much more.
The price is very reasonable. There were a couple of complaints that the jars had an expiration date that was soon after receiving their shipment, but this seems to depend more on the seller than the manufacturer.
Made from only one ingredient, peanut free, dairy free, gluten and sugar free, natural taste, smooth texture.
It is very important to check the expiration dates, the flavor may be too intense for some.
Best Creamy Coconut Butter
What You Will Love: This delicious brand of coconut butter comes with an e-book of coconut butter recipes.
Coconut Country Living Organic Coconut Butter is 100% pure coconut cream pureed concentrate. It is made from coconuts from Sri Lanka in a nut- and gluten-free environment.
It is packaged in 17.6 oz amounts in glass jars with no additives. In addition to using it as a spread and using it to make chocolates, buyers also enjoy using it as celery dip.
The price is very reasonable as it generally runs between $20 and $25 for two jars giving you a total of 35.26 oz.
The only complaint I have found thus far with the coconut butter is one that seems to be standard across the industry: the separation of the butter from the oil.
When it is shipped, and if it is stored in cold temperatures, you will see the separation. People who have not had coconut butter before are surprised by this and feel they have been given coconut oil instead.
There is a simple solution: either warm the jar in the microwave for a few seconds or in a hot water bath, then stir it up. It will then be nice and creamy.
Made from Sri Lankan coconuts in a nut-free and gluten free environment, great price, no additives.
New buyers may be surprised by the separation of oil and butter.
Adding coconut butter to your diet and beauty routine can give you incredible benefits.
All five options listed here in our Best Coconut Butter guide are great natural, tasty, and diet friendly choices. Try them for yourself to find one that fits your tastes and budget.